How a read receipt actually registers an open
Most read receipts work with a single, invisible one-pixel image embedded in your email. When the message is opened and that image loads from the tracker’s server, the open is recorded. Full mechanics are in how email open tracking works. The key point: no image load, no recorded open.
So what happens if images are off?
If the recipient has images fully blocked and never chooses to display them, the pixel does not load and that particular open will not show up. That is the honest limit of pixel tracking, and any tool claiming 100% accuracy is overselling.
But two things soften it a lot:
- Images are usually on. Gmail, Outlook.com and most clients load images by default now, frequently through their own proxy. Fully blocked images are the exception, not the rule.
- Link clicks still count. If your email has a link and the recipient clicks it, that registers even with images off. It is a stronger signal than a plain open anyway.
The bigger accuracy issue is the opposite problem
Today the more common distortion is not missed opens, it is false opens. Automated systems load your pixel without a human reading anything: Apple Mail Privacy Protection pre-fetches it, and corporate scanners open links to check them. A naive tracker counts these as reads. An honest one flags them instead, which is exactly how Vidi handles Apple Mail Privacy Protection.
What this means in practice
A read receipt gives you a strong, reliable signal for the large majority of emails, not a courtroom-grade guarantee for every single one. Vidi combines open and click signals, and is honest about automated loads, so a green tick means what it says: a real person opened your email. See the honest-open logic for yourself in the interactive demo.
Bottom line
Yes, a fully blocked image can hide one open, but it is uncommon and link tracking helps cover it. The accuracy you should actually care about is whether a tracker tells the truth about automated opens. Try Vidi, with a 30-day money-back guarantee, and see honest ticks on your next important email.